When it comes to eco-friendly deck options, balancing sustainability, recyclability, and longevity is crucial. Let's take an in-depth look at various materials and evaluate their environmental impact, recyclability, cost, and lifespan.
1. Composite Decking
Composite decking, such as Trex, is made from a blend of recycled plastics and wood fibers. While this approach reuses plastic waste, the final product is not recyclable due to the difficulty in separating the mixed materials. Companies like Trex recycle millions of plastic bags yearly, but the resulting composite boards end up in landfills after their useful life.
Lifespan: 25-30 years
Cost: $9-$12 per square foot
Environmental Impact: Uses recycled materials but ends up in landfills post-use.
Pros: Low maintenance, resistant to rot and insects.
Cons: Not recyclable, potential for heat retention.
2. PVC Decking
PVC (polyvinyl chloride) decking is fully recyclable. Despite this, its production relies on fossil fuels, making it less sustainable. Its production and disposal contribute to environmental pollution and greenhouse gas emissions.
Lifespan: 25-30 years
Cost: $10-$15 per square foot
Environmental Impact: High due to fossil fuel usage, but recyclable.
Pros: Recyclable, low maintenance, resistant to rot and insects.
Cons: High environmental cost of production, can become brittle over time.
3. Pressure-Treated Wood
Pressure-treated wood, typically southern pine, is infused with chemicals to resist rot and insect damage. This makes it non-recyclable and environmentally harmful due to the chemicals involved. Additionally, southern pine takes significantly longer to grow compared to bamboo, roughly twice as long, which further impacts its sustainability.
Lifespan: 10-15 years
Cost: $2-$5 per square foot
Environmental Impact: High due to chemical treatments and slower growth rate of source trees.
Pros: Cost-effective, resistant to rot and insects.
Cons: Non-recyclable, harmful chemicals, shorter lifespan.
4. Bamboo
Bamboo is an excellent sustainable option. It grows remarkably fast, with some species capable of growing up to 35 inches per day. Bamboo can reach maturity in 3 to 5 years, compared to several decades for most hardwoods. However, bamboo is not commonly recycled after use in decking, but its rapid growth and renewability make it a highly sustainable resource. Bamboo also absorbs more carbon dioxide and produces more oxygen than most trees, making it a significant carbon sink.
Lifespan: 15-20 years
Cost: $4-$6 per square foot
Environmental Impact: Low, as bamboo is fast-growing and renewable.
Pros: Sustainable, strong, and durable.
Cons: Not widely recycled, can be more expensive than treated wood.
5. Cedar
Cedar is a naturally rot-resistant wood that does not require chemical treatments, making it a more eco-friendly option compared to pressure-treated wood.
Lifespan: 15-20 years
Cost: $4-$8 per square foot
Environmental Impact: Moderate, as it is a renewable resource but takes longer to grow compared to bamboo.
Pros: Naturally rot-resistant, aesthetically pleasing, low chemical use.
Cons: Higher initial cost, requires maintenance.
Comparing Decking Structures
Douglas Fir vs. Pressure-Treated Wood vs. Steel
Douglas Fir:
Lifespan: 10-15 years untreated, up to 20 years with proper maintenance.
Cost: $2-$3 per square foot.
Environmental Impact: Lower chemical use compared to treated wood.
Pros: Naturally durable, eco-friendly, lower cost.
Cons: Requires regular maintenance, shorter lifespan.
Pressure-Treated Wood:
Lifespan: 15-20 years.
Cost: $2-$5 per square foot.
Environmental Impact: High due to chemical treatments.
Pros: Cost-effective, resistant to decay and insects.
Cons: Non-recyclable, environmental harm from chemicals.
Steel:
Lifespan: 50+ years.
Cost: $10-$15 per square foot.
Environmental Impact: Significant during production but recyclable at the end of its life.
Pros: Long-lasting, highly durable, recyclable.
Cons: High initial cost, potential for corrosion if not properly treated.
Additional Insights
Bamboo Growth vs. Southern Pine, Cedar, and Douglas Fir:
Bamboo can grow up to 35 inches per day and reaches maturity in 3-5 years, while southern pine and cedar take about 30 years to mature. Douglas fir typically takes 40-50 years to reach maturity.
Bamboo: 3-5 years
Southern Pine: 30 years
Cedar: 30 years
Douglas Fir: 40-50 years
Environmental Impact of Pressure-Treated Wood:
Pressure-treated wood contains chemicals like arsenic and copper, which can leach into the soil and water, posing environmental and health risks.
Recyclability Issues:
Composite decking, although made from recycled materials, cannot be recycled itself, leading to landfill accumulation.
Trex recycles millions of plastic bags annually but the final composite boards eventually end up in landfills, creating a double-edged sword of initial recycling followed by waste accumulation.
The Search for a Perfect Solution
No decking material is entirely sustainable and recyclable. Composite decking and PVC offer low maintenance but fall short in recyclability and sustainability. Pressure-treated wood is economical but environmentally harmful. Bamboo is highly sustainable but not typically recycled, while cedar offers a natural, aesthetically pleasing option with moderate environmental impact. Steel provides unmatched durability and recyclability but at a higher cost.
Choosing the best material involves balancing cost, durability, and environmental impact. Bamboo stands out for sustainability, while steel excels in durability. Cedar offers a good balance of eco-friendliness and natural resistance.
And if you’re still on the fence, just remember: building with bamboo means you could practically watch your deck grow. Meanwhile, your steel deck will outlast your next three backyard barbecues, and cedar will keep you swatting away carpenter bees while you admire its natural beauty.
Jacobe Palmiter @JCS Construction Services
Comments